YouTubal ligation
Nov. 18th, 2007 10:51 pmI was just watching this excellent video addressing the "blind watchmaker" analogy (suggested by
ruthling), and have to ask: does anyone find it possible to follow YouTube comment threads? There's only one level of nesting, for one thing, so if B replies to A and C replies to B, it looks like C has replied to A. More horribly, though, I see the same threads, and pieces of threads, appearing again and again in the comment stream — because, wherever one comment appears chronologically, the entire thread surrounding it appears with it. If A is posted on Monday, B is posted on Tuesday, and C is posted on Wednesday, then the A-B-C thread appears as a unit on Monday, and again on Tuesday, and again on Wednesday. Three comments become nine. This breaks many things, among them page and comment counts. In a thread with twenty replies, it quickly becomes ridiculous; I page backwards through the comments and see the same pages of replies again and again.
I wish the blind watchmaker who designed YouTube would step in.
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
I wish the blind watchmaker who designed YouTube would step in.